The Ultimate Clicker Countdown: Top 5 Picks for Positive Dog Training

A clicker might seem small, but it’s a mighty tool for dog training! The right clicker can boost your dog’s learning speed, strengthen your bond, and make training sessions fun for both of you. With so many options out there, we’ve narrowed down the field to bring you our top 5 picks for the best dog training clickers online.

Karen Pryor i-Click Clicker

The i-Click is a small handheld device that emits a clear clicking sound when pressed. It’s a powerful tool for positive reinforcement dog training, marking the exact moment your dog performs a desired behavior.


  • Designed by Experts: Karen Pryor is a pioneer in clicker training, and her products are known for quality and functionality.
  • Comfortable and Versatile: The i-Click is designed to be held in a variety of ways, making clicking easy regardless of your hand size or grip.
  • Quieter Click: The clicking sound is softer than traditional box clickers, ideal for sound-sensitive dogs.


  • Price: Slightly more expensive than some basic clickers.
  • Subtle Sound: If your dog prefers a louder click, this might not be the best option.

Best for: The i-Click is a great all-around choice for most dogs. It’s especially well-suited for:

  • Sound-sensitive breeds: The quieter click is gentler on their ears.
  • Puppy Training: Start puppies off with a positive training tool that won’t startle them.
  • Trainers with smaller hands or arthritis: The easy-to-use design is comfortable for everyone.

Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

Overall: The Karen Pryor i-Click is an excellent training tool backed by science and thoughtful design. While it might not be the cheapest clicker on the market, the quality and comfort make it a worthwhile investment for many dog owners.

Product Link:

StarMark Training Clicker

What it Does: Designed for positive reinforcement dog training, this clicker delivers a clear, attention-grabbing click to mark desired behaviors.


  • Ergonomic Comfort: Designed to fit comfortably in your hand, minimizing fatigue during training sessions.
  • Powerful Click: The louder click is ideal for dogs who thrive on clear auditory cues, and is helpful in more distracting environments.
  • Affordability: A reliable training tool at a budget-friendly price.
  • Visibility: Often comes in bright colors to prevent it from getting lost.


  • Sensitive Dogs: Might be too loud for some dogs with sensitive ears.
  • Durability: Some users report it may not be as durable with extended heavy use.

Best For: The StarMark Training Clicker is a solid option for:

  • Confident Dogs: Well-suited to dogs who respond best to strong feedback.
  • Outdoor Training: The louder click cuts through distractions in outdoor settings.
  • Budget-Conscious Owners: Effective and affordable for those starting with clicker training.

Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

Overall: The StarMark Training Clicker is a dependable choice for dog owners looking for a comfortable and effective clicker with a louder sound. If you have a sensitive pup, consider a softer clicker, but for most dogs, it’s a great tool to add to your training toolkit.

Amazon Link:

PetSafe Clik-R Trainer

What it Does: This basic clicker provides a simple and effective way to mark desired behaviors during positive reinforcement dog training.


  • Ultimate Affordability: A great starting point for those new to clicker training or on a tight budget.
  • No-Fuss Functionality: Straightforward design lets you focus on training your dog without distractions.
  • Wrist Strap: Keeps the clicker handy and prevents you from dropping it during sessions.


  • Quieter Click: The sound may be too subtle for some dogs, especially in noisy environments.
  • Lack of Features: No ergonomic design or other bells and whistles you might find in pricier clickers.

Best For: The PetSafe Clik-R Trainer is ideal for:

  • First-Time Clicker Users: Find out if clicker training is right for you and your dog without a big investment.
  • Adding to Your Toolkit: A handy backup clicker to have around the house or to keep in your car for on-the-go training sessions.
  • Multi-Dog Households: An affordable way to get a clicker in the hands of every family member involved in training.

Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

Overall: The PetSafe Clik-R Trainer does the job! It might not be the flashiest clicker, but if you want a no-frills tool to introduce clicker training concepts, it’s a solid and budget-friendly choice.

Product Link:

Mighty Paw Dog Training Clicker

What it Does: A simple yet effective tool for positive reinforcement dog training, delivering a clear click to help your dog understand desired behaviors.


  • Wearable Convenience: The retractable wrist lanyard frees up your hands and ensures you always have your clicker ready during training sessions.
  • Durable Design: Built to withstand regular use and accidental drops.
  • Affordability: Delivers great value with its practical features at a budget-friendly price.
  • Modern Look: Sleeker design compared to some traditional box-style clickers.


  • Click Sound: The click volume is more moderate, which may not be the best choice for very sound-driven dogs.
  • Lanyard Length: Some users might find the retractable lanyard a bit short.

Best For: The Mighty Paw Dog Training Clicker is perfect for:

  • On-the-Go Training: Ideal for walks, hikes, or training classes where keeping your clicker attached is a bonus.
  • Active Owners: Keeps your clicker secure even during dynamic training sessions.
  • Beginners: The simple, easy-to-use design with lanyard is great for those new to clicker training.

Rating: 4.25 out of 5 stars

Overall: The Mighty Paw Dog Training Clicker offers a practical and reliable clicker experience, especially for active training environments. Its key advantage is the secure wrist lanyard, adding convenience and preventing lost clickers.

Product Link:

Trixie Dog Activity Basic Clicker

This clicker provides positive reinforcement for dog training by marking correct behaviors with a distinct clicking sound.


  • Fun and Functional: The variety of bright colors adds a touch of playfulness to training sessions and helps prevent the clicker from getting lost.
  • Compact Design: Its small size and lightweight design make it easy to carry in your pocket or attach to a treat pouch.
  • Wallet-Friendly: One of the most affordable clicker options on the market.


  • Click Volume: The click is relatively soft, which may not be ideal for dogs who need stronger auditory feedback.
  • Basic Features: It lacks the ergonomic design or extra features like wrist straps found on some other clickers.

Best For: The Trixie Dog Activity Clicker is a good choice for:

  • First-Time Clicker Users: An inexpensive way to try out clicker training and see if it’s right for you and your dog.
  • Multi-Dog Households: Stock up on different colored clickers to help distinguish training sessions for each dog.
  • Travel Training: The small size is perfect for on-the-go training sessions.

Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

Overall: The Trixie Dog Activity Basic Clicker is a simple and budget-friendly tool for introducing clicker training principles. Its bright colors and compact design are its key selling points. If you seek a louder click or prioritize comfort, there may be better options for your needs.

Amazon Link:

Click Your Way to Success: Choosing the Best Clicker for You

Remember, the best clicker is the one that feels comfortable in your hand and works for your dog. Whether you prioritize a softer click for sensitive pups, an ergonomic design for your own ease, or maximum value for your money, there’s a clicker out there for your training team.

Have you tried clicker training? Share your favorite clicker in the comments below! We’d love to hear which tools work best for you and your furry friend.

Press ESC to close